Trade Your Magic Cards

Looking to trade your Magic: The Gathering collection? Dynamo Collectibles buys MTG singles, sealed products, Commander staples, and vintage cards. From Alpha to the latest set, we offer competitive prices for your Magic collection!

Begin Your Trade

Choose Dynamo

Why Trade With Dynamo?

Fair Offers

We base our trade values on current market conditions and ensure you're always getting a competitive deal.

No Pressure

Take your time to review our offer. We want every customer to feel confident in their decision.

Immediate Credit or Cash

Walk out with your trade completed instantly, no waiting around!

First things first

Trade Rules

These trade rules are designed to ensure a fair and efficient trading environment for all collectors. Please review the guidelines below to understand our criteria and conditions for trading, including the options for cash and store credit.

If you have any questions please call the store at (239) 494-2344

Graded Cards
We accept graded Magic: The Gathering cards from all major grading services. All grades from 1 through 10 are welcome.
Damaged Cards
Damaged cards are welcome, but their acceptance is determined on a case-by-case basis by our store associates. They will evaluate the condition of each card and decide whether it meets our criteria for trade-ins.
Cash and Credit
All trades can be completed using either cash or store credit. If you choose to receive cash, please be aware that the cash buy-back rate will be lower compared to the rate offered for store credit. You also have the option to receive a combination of cash and credit, with the credit portion pro-rated to ensure maximum value received for your trade-in.
Bulk
We do not accept bulk trade-ins for common or uncommon cards. Focus on rares, mythics, and playable cards. This policy helps us maintain a higher standard of quality in our card inventory.

Submit your trade online

How to submit your Magic trade using tcgsearch

Start Your Trade on tcgsearch
  1. 1

    Name Your Trade

    Start your trade and enter your name

  2. 2

    Select Your TCG

    Choose Pokemon, Magic, One Piece, or more

  3. 3

    Add Your Items

    Search and add cards or sealed products

  4. 4

    Send to Shop

    Submit your trade for review

Or start your trade now

Questions? Give us a call at (239) 494-2344

Visit Our Store

Looking to evaluate your collection or just on the hunt for that perfect card? Visit us at Dynamo Collectibles in Fort Myers, FL! Our team is ready to assist with quotes, trades, and helping you find the next great addition to your collection.

Store Hours
Monday - Wednesday
11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Thursday
11:30 AM - 7:00 PM
Friday - Sunday
11:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Store Address
15250 S Tamiami Tri #114
Fort Myers, FL 33908